Wednesday, October 7, 2009

Cannibalizing or Cannibalized, Which Is It?

As mentioned in a previous post, see the September 30th post While Watching the Senate.., the Republicans are now taking care of Seniors and Medicare. Interesting how the same words get used by the same party but in different contexts.

In an exchange and surprisingly adult conversation on ABC Sunday Morning, Sen. Schumer (D of NY) and Sen. Cornyn (R. of TX)discussed and agreed on much. Then it came. Sen. Cornyn must have realized he hadn't used any Republican talking points. Someone flipped a switch and the Seniors on Medicare became the victims of... are you ready...hold it comes; "cannibalization". here is the link watch all of it.

How do they do it with a straight face? One minute seniors are cannibalizing; the next minute they are being cannibalized. Law of the Jungle-eat or be eaten? Do you remember Judge Janice R. Brown? I do.

I remember she said that today's seniors were cannibals and wanted all the free stuff they could get. quote here Now I am sure we were aware she was speaking figuratively but my point is the use of the word cannibalize. Judge Brown has a very interesting history both life story and words spoken. More about the 2004 appointments and the arguments here
and see for a speech listing more of the Judges statements

Why did Sen. Cornyn use that particular word? Did someone in the Repub. party do a poll back in 2000 to see if it got significant reaction? Did they decide that seniors did react in disgust so let's use it again but to another advantage?
One more way to scare seniors away from health care reform?

Who knows. I do know I reacted in both cases. I really got incensed when the Judge used it and Sunday I was first surprised then angered by the way it was brought out of mothballs.

By the way if you want some real laughs about words and the way they are used and the way things change check out Pres. G.W. Bush's acceptance speech at the 2004 Republican

Of particular interest to me:
...This changed world can be a time of great opportunity for all Americans to earn a better living, support your family, and have a rewarding career. And government must take your side....

Thanks to our policies, homeownership in America is at an all-time high. Tonight we set a new goal: seven million more affordable home in the next 10 years so more American families will be able to open the door and say welcome to my home.

(Laughter here is allowed. Are we talking about tents? Actually the homes did get more affordable, or rather the "loans" did.)

Sorry, back to the speech:

...Because we acted to defend our country, the murderous regimes of Saddam Hussein and the Taliban are history...

"Mission Accomplished"

So yes, Politicians play with words. But, me thinks the Repubs. are the best at it.


  1. Lanna, I sure do admire your clear-eyed strength and tenacity in keeping up with the daily political happenings and such. I find it overwhelming with no fix in sight. Depressing, really. I am already preparing myself to die a painful lingering-death without medical aid. The Indians knew how to do it, and animals, too. Instead of following the daily news-downers, I think I will just sit on my porch and contemplate the positive, fuzzy 'what-ifs' instead.

    OH!--I finally figured how to post again--thanks to That's a great help site.

  2. Here is the link to BlogDR
    I just put a hot link on yesterday's Problem post.

  3. Thanks Pat.
    I will check it out when the brain works again.

  4. This is interesting and kinda goes with my recent post and one that I wrote some time ago... But, your angle on this is something to think about. I wish my brain was working better and that I had more time right now to post a better comment, but I hope to spend more time here and on my blog and the ones that I follow, soon.

    Floors are almost done.. that will be my next post, or I will post the pictures on picassa.. I will let you guys know what has been taking my time.

  5. That link is a great post Thomas has written.
    He gets right to the point and makes a lot of sense.
    I highly recommend you read Thomas' blog.
    I also have a link to his blog on my blogs I follow.
    Don't let him fool you here. Thomas has a good "brain" and he lets it reach out in many directions.
    Pictures would be great on the floors. I wish I had your energy.